Is small claims court for unpaid invoices better than a collection agency?
Small claims court for unpaid invoices works best in specific situations.
Use small claims court when the amount fits your state’s limit, you know where the debtor is, they can pay, and you have time to prepare and attend. Use a collection agency when the debtor is unresponsive or hard to find, the amount is larger, or you’d rather a professional handle it on contingency.
Small claims court for unpaid invoices vs. an agency
Small claims costs filing fees and your time, and produces a judgment you may still need to enforce. An agency usually costs nothing upfront and takes a percentage of recovery; published ranges run 20%–50%[source]. Full comparison: small claims vs. collection agency.
More answers
- Customer won’t pay invoice: what do I do?
- What legal action for unpaid invoices can I take if a customer refuses to pay?
- Can you write off unpaid invoices?
- How much do collection agencies charge?
- Who pays collection agency fees: me or the debtor?
- How do I write a payment demand letter?
- Can I hire a collection agency to collect a debt that’s small?
- How to hire a collection agency: what are the steps?
- How to send someone to collections: what are the steps?
Sources: Business News Daily, “The Best Collection Agency Services” (page last updated Oct 17, 2024) (accessed Oct 18, 2026).
Owed money by another business?
Tell us about the unpaid invoice and we’ll match you with an experienced collection partner suited to its size, age and location. Matching is free.
Get matched with a collection partner